One Sentence Cannot Fix a System

Russell Brand has been jailed for ten and a half years. Here's why that should not be the exception.

On Monday 9 November, Russell Brand was sentenced at Southwark Crown Court to ten and a half years in prison for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault. The sentence reflects the seriousness of the harm he caused.

Rape is never a "moment" or a misunderstanding. It is a crime that can affect every part of a survivor's life, often for many years. And this sentence belongs, above all, to the women who came forward.

The women who refused to be silenced

For years, these women carried what he did to them. Then they stood in court and gave evidence against one of the most recognisable men in the country, a man with a platform of millions.

They faced cross-examination about their memories, their motives and their behaviour, under intense public scrutiny. They saw it through, and they were believed. Their courage made this outcome possible, and we thank them.

The myths survivors face in court

During the trial, the jury heard arguments that survivors and the people who support them will recognise:

  • Delay: the defence called the years before the women went to the police "monstrous", as if delay made their accounts less true. Many survivors only feel able to come forward years later, often once someone else has gone first.

  • Motive: the women were asked why they came forward when they did, and accused of being influenced by the media. In the defence's words, a documentary had "poisoned the well of justice".

  • Bad behaviour, not a crime: the jury was told that being "a crazy idiot towards women is not a crime". That is true, but it was used to draw the line around rape as narrowly as possible.

These are not just legal tactics. They are rape myths: false, harmful beliefs about how "real" victims behave. Every survivor who is weighing up whether to report hears them too.

Myths in real time

Rape myths are devastating to survivors. They no longer stay in a courtroom or a conversation. They play out in real time across the media and online, where they are shared, repeated and amplified within minutes.

When the allegations against Brand were first reported in 2023, he did not step back. He spoke directly to millions of followers online and told them it was a coordinated attack. Throughout this case, comment sections and social feeds have carried the same claims: that the women lied, wanted money, or were part of a conspiracy.

These ideas are increasingly being normalised in the manosphere, where misogyny is packaged as entertainment. Young men are taught that women lie, that consent is negotiable and that women who come forward are the enemy. Celebrities were once protected by their industry. Now they can be protected by an audience.

One sentence cannot fix a system

This case should not be the exception, but it is. Fewer than three in every hundred rapes recorded by police in 2024 led to a charge. Fewer than one in six women who are raped or sexually assaulted tell the police at all.

Survivors tell us why. They fear they won't be believed. They blame themselves. Often the person who harmed them is someone they know, love or work with. They dread years of waiting, intrusive requests for their phone and counselling notes, and cross-examination that puts their character on trial. And they have seen how women in high-profile cases are treated.

Most survivors will never see the inside of a courtroom, let alone hear a jury say they were believed. The man who isn't famous usually gets away with it too. He just does it without the headlines.

What needs to change

The Law Commission's 2025 report on sexual offences prosecutions explicitly warns that rape myths can influence trials. It recommends reforms so that juries are not swayed by them. We want those recommendations put into law without delay, and we are calling for:

  1. Myth-busting jury directions at the start of every rape trial. Jurors don't arrive as blank slates. They need to understand from the outset that there is no single way a victim behaves, including freezing, staying in contact with the person who harmed them, or taking years to come forward.

  2. Expert evidence on how survivors respond to sexual violence, as the Law Commission recommends, so that trauma is not mistaken for inconsistency.

  3. Properly and sustainably funded specialist services, so survivors are supported before, during and long after any trial.

  4. Consent and healthy relationships education strong enough to counter what young people are learning online.

  5. Accountability for the institutions that look the other way, whether broadcasters, employers or anyone else who enables abuse.

If you need support

If coverage of this case has brought up difficult feelings, you are not alone, and it is never too late to get support. Whatever happened, and however long ago, you deserve to be heard.

The 24/7 Rape and Sexual Abuse Support Line is free and confidential: 0808 500 2222. You can also visit rapecrisissouthlondon.org.

We believe you.

Next
Next

London’s Victims’ Commissioner Andrea Simon visits Rape Crisis South London